The Philosophy of Anaxagoras
Ep. 92

The Philosophy of Anaxagoras

Episode description

Picture this: Athens, 450 BCE. The most powerful democracy in the ancient world. The cultural and intellectual center of civilization. Philosophy, drama, art—everything that will define Western culture for the next two thousand years is happening right here, right now. And in the middle of all this brilliance, there’s a man standing in the agora—the marketplace—looking up at the sun. Not praying to it. Not worshiping it. Just… looking. Thinking. Asking questions. And then he says something that will change everything: “The sun is not a god. It’s a rock. A massive, burning rock hurtling through space.” His name is Anaxagoras. And that statement? That simple, observational claim? It’s going to get him exiled from the city he helped transform into an intellectual powerhouse.

“Hello, curious minds! I’m Lyon Leshley, a passionate educator with over 20 years of experience. I am taking full advantage of the AI revolution to provide free education content. At my YouTube, Rumble, and Odysee channels we dive deep into the fascinating worlds of philosophy, history, literature, science, and so much more.”

Education is more than just learning—it’s a journey of growth, discovery, and enlightenment. Whether you’re a student, a lifelong learner, or just someone who loves to explore new ideas, my channel is your gateway to knowledge.“

“And the best part? Every lecture comes with a free e-book download on Gumroad, and all my content is available in 20 different languages, ensuring that knowledge knows no boundaries.”

“Join learners from around the globe as we break down barriers and make education accessible to everyone. You can find all my social media links and support this mission by visiting my webpage at leshley.ca or my Gravatar page at gravatar.com/lyonleshley. If you’d like to donate directly, head over to my Gumroad page at https://shop.leshley.ca/coffee

Video lectures with subtitles translated into 28 languages are available at https://www.youtube.com/@learn.w.leshley and https://tube.leshley.ca/

Download transcript (.srt)
0:00

Picture this. Athens. 450 BCE. The most powerful democracy in the ancient world. The cultural

0:09

and intellectual center of civilization. Philosophy, drama, art. Everything that will define Western

0:16

culture for the next 2,000 years is happening right here, right now. And in the middle of

0:20

all this brilliance, there's a man standing in the Agora, the marketplace, looking up at

0:25

the sun, not praying to it, not worshipping it, just looking. thinking, asking questions.

0:31

And then he says something that will change everything. The sun is not a god. It's a rock.

0:38

A massive burning rock hurtling through space. His name is Anaxagoras. And that statement,

0:44

that simple observational claim, it's going to get him exiled from the city he helped transform

0:49

into an intellectual powerhouse. But here's what's remarkable. Here's what should make

0:54

your heart race. Anaxagoras doesn't stop there. He looks at the entire universe and says, everything

1:01

you think you know about reality is wrong. Matter isn't made of simple elements. The cosmos isn't

1:07

governed by capricious gods. And intelligence, mind itself, is woven into the fabric of existence.

1:14

Now, I know what you're thinking. Okay, another dead Greek guy with weird ideas about the universe.

1:21

Why should I care? Here's why. An axagoras is asking questions we're still grappling with

1:28

today. What is consciousness? How does order emerge from chaos? Is the universe fundamentally

1:35

intelligent or fundamentally meaningless? These aren't ancient puzzles gathering dust in philosophy

1:41

departments. These are live questions at the cutting edge of physics, neuroscience, and

1:45

philosophy of mind. But more than that, more than the ideas themselves, Anaxagoras shows

1:52

us what it costs to pursue truth. He had everything. Influence, Friendship with the most powerful

1:58

man in Athens, respect, security. And he lost it all because he refused to lie about what

2:04

he saw when he looked at the sky. He chose truth over safety. He chose understanding over orthodoxy.

2:12

He chose to challenge the most fundamental beliefs of his society even though he knew, he knew,

2:17

it would destroy him. And you know what? His ideas survived. They influenced Socrates, Plato,

2:23

Aristotle, every philosopher who came after. They echo in quantum mechanics, in theories

2:29

of consciousness, in cosmology. Two and a half thousand years later, we're still wrestling

2:33

with the questions he asked. So today, we're going to explore the philosophy of Anaxagoras.

2:39

We're going to dive into his revolutionary theory that everything contains everything else. We're

2:44

going to examine his concept of nous, cosmic mind, and why it changed philosophy forever.

2:49

We're going to see how his astronomical observations challenged religious orthodoxy and why that

2:55

matters. But most importantly, we're going to ask ourselves, what would we be willing to

2:59

sacrifice for truth? What orthodoxies are we afraid to challenge? And what does it mean

3:05

to live in a universe where intelligence underlies order and everything is connected to everything

3:09

else? Anaxagoras looked at the Sun and saw a rock. But in doing so, he saw something far

3:16

more profound. He saw that the universe is comprehensible. That reason can guide us. that we don't have

3:23

to accept the stories we're told just because everyone believes them. That's not just ancient

3:28

philosophy. That's a challenge to how you live your life right now today. So let's meet the

3:33

man behind the mind. Let's understand what made Anaxagoras so dangerous, so influential,

3:41

and so absolutely essential to everything that came after. This is Anaxagoras of Clazomenes,

3:49

and his story, it's going to change how you see the world. Let's begin. Alright, let's

3:54

talk about one of the most fascinating figures in ancient philosophy, a man who literally

3:59

changed the course of Western thought and then got kicked out of town for his trouble. His

4:04

name? Anaxagoras. Now here's what's remarkable about this guy. Born around 500 BCE in Ionia,

4:11

that's modern-day Turkey, Anaxagoras did something no other pre-Socratic philosopher had done

4:16

before. He packed up his ideas and moved to Athens. Think about that for a second. Athens

4:22

wasn't just any city, it was becoming the intellectual and cultural powerhouse of the ancient world.

4:28

And Anaxagoras? He was the first philosopher to set up shop there and start teaching. But

4:33

this wasn't just some academic migration. This was a pivotal moment in the history of ideas.

4:38

For three decades, Anaxagoras lived and taught in Athens, becoming close friends with Pericles

4:44

himself. You know, the guy who basically defined Athenian democracy and culture during its golden

4:50

age. Imagine having that kind of access, that kind of influence. Anaxagoras was right there

4:55

at the center of power, introducing scientific rationalism to the very heart of Greek civilization.

5:01

And here's where it gets interesting, and by interesting, I mean dangerous. See, Anaxagoras

5:07

had this radical idea that the sun wasn't a god, it was just a fiery rock. A massive incandescent

5:13

piece of metal hurtling through space. To us, that sounds obvious, right? But in ancient

5:19

Athens, that was heresy, that was impiety. That was the kind of thing that could get you killed,

5:25

and it nearly did. Eventually, his materialistic explanations, his insistence on natural causes

5:31

rather than divine intervention, led to formal charges of impiety. He was forced into exile,

5:36

driven out of the very city he'd helped transform intellectually. You know what this tells us?

5:41

Philosophy has always been dangerous. The pursuit of truth has always threatened established

5:46

power. And sometimes asking the right questions costs you everything. Okay, so now we get to

5:51

the really mind-bending stuff. Anaxagoras looked at the world around him and asked a question

5:56

that philosophers had been wrestling with for generations. What is everything made of? Now

6:02

his predecessors had answers. Thales said water. Anaximenes said air. Heraclitus said fire.

6:09

Eventually, you get this idea of four basic elements. Earth, air, fire, water, and boom.

6:16

That's your periodic table. Ancient style. Anaxagoras said, Nope, you're all wrong. Here's his revolutionary

6:22

idea, and I want you to really sit with this because it's genuinely weird. Everything contains

6:27

a portion of everything else. Every. Single. Thing. Look at this slide here. Infinite division.

6:37

That gold bar you're looking at? According to Anaxagoras, it contains traces of bananas and

6:44

rhinoceroses. and your coffee cup, and the stars, and literally everything else in the universe.

6:51

Nothing is ever truly pure or separate. Wait, you're thinking, that's insane. A gold bar

6:57

is obviously just gold. And here's where Anaxagoras gets clever. He introduces what we call the

7:03

predominance principle. Yes, that gold bar contains everything, but it appears as gold

7:09

because gold predominates in the mixture. The gold is so overwhelmingly present that it drowns

7:14

out all the other stuff. Think about what this means philosophically. Anaxagoras is rejecting

7:21

the very idea of indivisible, fundamental elements. He's saying reality is infinitely divisible,

7:28

constantly mixed, always in flux. There's no bottom to matter, no final building block where

7:33

you can say, aha! This is what everything is really made of. And here's what blows my mind

7:38

about this. Anaxagoras is anticipating ideas that wouldn't be fully developed for over 2,000

7:45

years. Modern quantum mechanics tells us that matter is far stranger and more complex than

7:50

our senses reveal. That the universe at its most fundamental level is a churning sea of

7:56

probability and potential. That separation and distinction might be useful illusions rather

8:00

than ultimate truths. So when you look at this slide showing dynamic cosmos, this vision of

8:07

reality is constantly mixed and infinitely divisible, you're not just looking at ancient philosophy.

8:13

You're looking at one of the first attempts to grapple with a truth that still challenges

8:17

us today. The universe is far weirder than it appears, and our common sense is a terrible

8:23

guide to ultimate reality. Anaxagoras knew this 2,500 years ago, and Athens kicked him out

8:29

for it. Makes you wonder what truths we're ignoring today because they're too uncomfortable, doesn't

8:34

it? Alright, so we've got this wild theory, everything contains everything else, but let's

8:39

make this concrete. Let's actually see what Anaxagoras is talking about. Picture this.

8:44

Imagine a cosmic soup. Not just any soup, but THE soup. The primordial mixture at the beginning

8:51

of everything. And in this soup, all the ingredients that will ever exist are already there, swirling

8:58

together simultaneously. Flesh, bone, gold, wood, water, fire, thought, sensation, everything,

9:03

all mixed together in infinite proportions. Now here's the thing, and this is crucial,

9:07

What we perceive as separate, distinct objects are just different arrangements of this cosmic

9:12

mixture. That tree outside? It's not fundamentally different from the rock next to it. They're

9:18

both the same primordial stuff, just with different proportions. The tree has more tree-ness, predominating.

9:25

The rock has more rock-ness, but they both contain traces of each other and everything

9:31

else. You see what he's doing here? Anaxagoras is telling us that our senses lie to us. We

9:37

look around and see a world of separate things. You, me, this podium, that wall. We think these

9:44

are fundamentally different substances, but according to Anaxagoras, that's an illusion.

9:49

Underneath the apparent diversity, there's an underlying unity. We're all made of the same

9:54

cosmic mixture, just in different proportions. And look at the second part of this slide,

10:00

Legacy and Influence. This isn't just some quirky ancient idea that got left in the dustbin of

10:06

history. No. This concept laid essential groundwork for everything that came after. Democritus

10:13

and his atoms? He's building on Anaxagoras' insight that reality is more complex than appearances

10:19

suggest. Modern physics and our understanding of matter at the quantum level? Same thing.

10:26

We've discovered that what looks solid and separate is actually mostly empty space, vibrating fields,

10:32

particles that pop in and out of existence. But here's what really matters philosophically.

10:37

Anaxagoras is forcing us to question the reliability of perception itself. If appearances deceive

10:43

us about something as basic as what things are made of, what else are we wrong about? How

10:49

much of what we take for granted about reality is just... mistaken? That's not just ancient

10:54

philosophy, that's a live question that should keep you up at night. Okay, now we get to the

10:59

really revolutionary part. Because Anaxagoras has just told us that everything is mixed together

11:05

in this cosmic soup, right? So here's the obvious question. How did we get from primordial chaos

11:11

to the ordered cosmos we see around us? How did that soup become... well, everything?

11:17

And here's where Anaxagoras introduces something absolutely unprecedented in Greek philosophy.

11:23

Naus. Mind. Cosmic intelligence. Look at this first point. Infinite intelligence. News is

11:30

infinite, pure... and entirely unmixed. Let that sink in. Remember, Anaxagoras just spent

11:37

all this time telling us that everything contains everything else. But Noose, Noose is the one

11:42

thing that's not blended with anything. It stands alone, completely separate from the material

11:49

mixture. Why? Because Noose has a job to do. Look at the second point, Prime Mover. Noose

11:57

initiates cosmic motion by setting the primordial mixture into rotation. Picture this. You've

12:04

got this infinite chaotic soup of everything mixed together, and Noose comes along and gives

12:09

it a spin. Literally. A cosmic rotation that gradually causes separation and formation of

12:14

the ordered universe we inhabit. But here's what makes this philosophically profound. Noose

12:21

isn't just force. It's not just mechanical energy. Look at that third point. Pure force. Noose

12:27

is intelligent. It's self-controlling. Autonomous. possessing immense power over all things. This

12:34

is the first time in Western philosophy that someone introduces intelligence as a fundamental

12:39

cosmic principle. Do you understand what a massive shift this is? Before Anaxagoras, you've got

12:44

mythological explanations. Zeus did this, Poseidon did that. Or you've got purely mechanical explanations.

12:51

It's all just water or air or fire. But Anaxagoras says no. There's an intelligent principle governing

12:57

the cosmos. Not a god in the traditional sense, but mind itself, rational, purposeful, ordering.

13:04

And look at this last one. Governor of life, who governs all living things, from the smallest

13:10

creatures to the vast movements of celestial bodies. Everything that moves, everything that

13:16

lives, is under the direction of this cosmic intelligence. Now, here's what's fascinating,

13:21

and we'll see this play out in the next slide. This idea of gnos will absolutely captivate

13:27

later philosophers. Socrates hears about it and gets excited. Plato builds his entire theory

13:33

of the Demiurge on it. Aristotle engages with it critically but respectfully. Because Anaxagoras

13:39

has done something extraordinary, he's bridged the gap between myth and rational explanation.

13:44

He's given us a way to talk about cosmic order and purpose without resorting to anthropomorphic

13:49

gods, but also without reducing everything to blind mechanical forces. Mind orders the cosmos.

13:55

Intelligence underlies reality. That's the claim. And whether you agree with it or not, you have

14:01

to admit, it's a hell of a lot more interesting than the gods did it. And it's a question we're

14:06

still wrestling with today. Is the universe fundamentally intelligent? Is mind a basic

14:11

feature of reality, or just an accident of evolution? And Exagoras put that question on the table

14:17

2500 years ago. We still don't have a definitive answer. Alright, so we've established that

14:22

NUS, this cosmic mind, exists, and that it set the universe spinning. But now we need to ask

14:28

What can it actually do? What are its powers? And this is where Anaxagoras gets really specific.

14:34

Look at this first point on the slide. Perfect knowledge. New possess complete and perfect

14:39

knowledge of all things. Not just the things we can see now, not just the ordered cosmos

14:44

we inhabit, but both. Both those mixed together in the primordial chaos and those separated

14:49

in the ordered cosmos. Think about what that means. Before anything existed in distinct

14:55

form, before there were stars or planets or people, Nuh's already knew it all. Past, present,

15:01

future, all of it transparent to this cosmic intelligence. But knowledge alone isn't enough,

15:07

right? So look at the second point. Cosmic ordering. Nuh doesn't just know, it orders. It directs

15:16

the entire cosmos with what Anaxagoras calls discerning judgment. This isn't random, this

15:21

isn't chaotic. Nuh determines the proper arrangement and motion of all substances with purpose and

15:27

intelligence. Now here's where it gets philosophically crucial. Look at that third point, immense

15:33

strength. News wields the greatest strength of anything in existence. It has the power

15:38

to initiate that cosmic rotation we talked about, to transform absolute chaos into cosmic order.

15:44

And here's what you need to understand about what Anaxagoras is doing here. This is one

15:49

of the earliest philosophical attempts, maybe the earliest, to explain cosmic order through

15:54

intelligence rather than mythology. Before this, If you wanted to know why the world is ordered,

15:59

you'd get stories about gods fighting, gods creating, gods intervening. But Anaxagoras

16:05

says, no, there's a rational principle at work. Mind itself operating according to its own

16:11

nature, bringing order out of chaos. This is a profound shift toward rational explanation,

16:17

and it's going to echo through the entire Western philosophical tradition. Every time someone

16:23

asks, why is there order rather than chaos? they're walking in Anaxagoras' footsteps. But,

16:29

and here's the tension we'll see later, Anaxagoras introduces this brilliant concept of cosmic

16:34

intelligence, and then... he doesn't always use it consistently. He'll explain some things

16:39

through Naus and other things through purely mechanical causes, and that inconsistency?

16:43

That's going to drive Socrates and Aristotle absolutely crazy. But we're getting ahead of

16:48

ourselves.

16:55

Okay, now we get to the part where Anaxagoras becomes genuinely dangerous, because it's one

17:00

thing to have abstract theories about cosmic mixtures in mind, but Anaxagoras didn't stop

17:06

there. He looked up at the sky and started asking questions that would get him exiled. Look at

17:11

this. Revolutionary astronomy. Anaxagoras correctly explained eclipses through the interposition

17:17

of celestial bodies. Now, to us that sounds obvious, right? The moon passes in front of

17:23

the sun. we get an eclipse. Simple. But in ancient Athens, eclipses were terrifying supernatural

17:30

events. Signs from the gods. Omens of disaster. And here comes Anaxagoras saying, Nope, it's

17:38

just geometry. One thing passing in front of another thing. No gods required. And he didn't

17:44

stop there. He argued that the sun, the sun is a hot incandescent metal mass. Not Apollo's

17:50

chariot. Not a deity. just a big fiery rock. And the moon? The moon is earthy, reflecting

17:58

the sun's light rather than generating its own. But wait, it gets better. Or worse, depending

18:06

on your perspective. Anaxagoras even suggested that there might be inhabitants on the moon

18:10

in 450 BCE. This guy is speculating about lunar civilizations while most people think the moon

18:17

is a goddess. Now here's where we need to understand the stakes. Look at that bottom section of

18:22

the slide. His naturalistic explanations directly challenged religious orthodoxy. And in Athens,

18:28

that wasn't just controversial. It was prosecutable. Plato's Apology, you know, the dialogue about

18:34

Socrates' trial, actually references Anaxagoras' controversial ideas. Even decades later, these

18:40

theories were still being used as examples of dangerous thinking. The tension between philosophy

18:45

and traditional religion wasn't abstract. It was real, and it had consequences. Anaxagoras

18:51

was eventually charged with impiety and forced into exile. Think about that. He correctly

18:56

explained eclipses. He understood that celestial bodies are natural objects operating according

19:02

to natural laws. He removed supernatural explanations and demonstrated nature's mechanical operations.

19:08

And Athens kicked him out for it. You know what this tells us? The pursuit of truth has always

19:14

been dangerous. Challenging Orthodoxy, whether religious, political, or cultural. has always

19:19

come with risks. Anaxagoras paid the price for insisting that we should explain the world

19:24

through observation and reason rather than myth and tradition. But here's the thing. He was

19:29

right. His astronomical observations were correct. His naturalistic approach was sound. And even

19:36

though Athens exiled him, his ideas survived. They influenced Socrates, Plato, Aristotle,

19:42

the entire philosophical tradition that followed. So here's my question for you. What truths

19:48

are we afraid to speak today? What orthodoxies are we unwilling to challenge because the cost

19:53

seems too high? Anaxagoras shows us that sometimes the most important ideas are the most dangerous

19:59

ones. And sometimes being right isn't enough. You also have to be brave. Alright, so Anaxagoras

20:05

gets exiled, right? His ideas are too dangerous for Athens. But here's the beautiful irony.

20:12

Even though the city kicked him out, his philosophy didn't die. In fact, it became absolutely central

20:18

to everything that came after. Let's trace this legacy through the big three, Socrates, Plato,

20:23

and Aristotle. Because each of them wrestled with Anaxagoras' ideas in fascinating ways,

20:29

look at number one, influence on Socrates. Now, we know about Socrates primarily through Plato's

20:35

dialogues, and in the Phaedo, that's the dialogue about Socrates' last day before his execution,

20:42

Socrates tells this story about his intellectual journey. He says he was initially thrilled

20:47

when he heard about Anaxagoras' idea that mind orders all things. Finally, someone saying

20:52

that intelligence, not blind chance, governs the cosmos. Socrates thought, this is it. Anaxagoras

20:59

will explain how mind arranges everything for the best. But then Socrates actually read Anaxagoras'

21:05

work and he was let down. Because Anaxagoras would invoke mind to explain the initial cosmic

21:11

rotation. But then he'd explain everything else through purely mechanical causes. Air, ether,

21:17

vortices. He introduced this brilliant concept of cosmic intelligence and then barely used

21:22

it. Socrates wanted teleological explanations. Explanations based on purpose and goodness.

21:28

Why is the Earth here? Because it's best for it to be here. But Anaxagoras would say, the

21:35

Earth is here because of mechanical forces. And Socrates thought, you had one job. You

21:41

introduced mind and then you forgot about it. Now look at number two. Impact on Plato. Plato

21:47

takes Anaxagoras' concept of noose and absolutely runs with it. He transforms it into his theory

21:53

of the demiurge, the divine craftsman who orders the cosmos according to eternal forms. In Plato's

21:59

Timaeus, you get this cosmic intelligence that looks at perfect eternal forms and shapes the

22:05

material world to resemble them as closely as possible. That's Anaxagoras' noose on steroids.

22:11

Plato took the seed of the idea and grew it into a full cosmological and metaphysical system.

22:17

So even though Plato criticizes Anaxagoras for the same reason Socrates did, not using mind

22:22

consistently enough, he also owes him an enormous debt. Without Anaxagoras, there's no demiurge.

22:28

Without Anaxagoras, Plato's entire cosmic vision looks very different. And then we get to Aristotle.

22:33

Look at this. Aristotle's response. Now, Aristotle is fascinating because he both praises and

22:38

criticizes Anaxagoras in really specific ways. Aristotle says Anaxagoras was like a sober

22:44

man among the drunk for introducing mind as a cosmic principle. Everyone else was stumbling

22:50

around with purely material explanations, and Anaxagoras had the clarity to see that you

22:55

need intelligence to explain cosmic order. But, and this is a big but, Aristotle also says

23:00

Anaxagoras uses mind like a deus ex machina. You know that term? It's from Greek theater,

23:06

when the playwright can't figure out how to resolve the plot, they just lower a god onto

23:10

the stage with a crane to fix everything. That's what Anaxagoras does with mind, according to

23:15

Aristotle. Whenever he can't explain something mechanically, he just says, mind did it. And

23:21

when he can explain it mechanically, he ignores mind entirely. So all three of these giants,

23:27

Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, they're all grappling with the same tension in Anaxagoras' thought.

23:34

He introduced something brilliant and revolutionary, but he didn't fully develop it. He gave philosophy

23:40

this incredible gift, the idea that intelligence underlies cosmic order. But he didn't unwrap

23:46

it completely. Look at this. Materialism meets teleology. That's exactly the tension. Anaxagoras

23:56

is trying to blend materialistic physics, everything is matter in motion, with purposeful intelligence.

24:01

Mind orders things for reasons. And that blend? That's a philosophical problem that we're still

24:07

working on today. Is the universe fundamentally material, with consciousness as an accidental

24:13

byproduct? Or is intelligence fundamental, with matter as its expression? Anaxagoras put both

24:19

ideas on the table and didn't fully resolve the tension between them. And finally, look

24:24

at this last point. Proto-scientific method. Because here's what Anaxagoras really gave

24:30

us. an empirical, naturalistic approach to understanding nature beyond myth. He said, let's look at

24:35

the evidence, let's observe eclipses, study celestial bodies, examine the natural world,

24:40

and explain it through natural causes. That's the scientific method in embryonic form. That's

24:47

the foundation of everything that comes after. And even though he got exiled for it, even

24:51

though Athens rejected it, that approach to knowledge survived and transformed the world.

24:57

Okay, so we've traced Anaxagoras' influence through ancient philosophy, but here's the

25:02

question that really matters. Why should you care about this guy in 2025? What does a philosopher

25:07

from 2500 years ago have to say to us today? Turns out, a lot. Look at this first one. Matter

25:13

and composition. Anaxagoras' vision of infinite divisibility and universal mixture, everything

25:19

containing everything else, this actually foreshadows modern quantum mechanics in really eerie ways.

25:25

Think about quantum entanglement. Particles that were once connected remain connected across

25:30

vast distances. Or think about quantum field theory, the idea that what we call particles

25:36

are just excitations in underlying fields that permeate all of space. Or the fact that at

25:42

the quantum level, the boundaries between things become fuzzy and uncertain. Anaxagoras didn't

25:47

have the math or the experimental apparatus, obviously, but he had the philosophical insight.

25:53

Matter is far more complex than appearances suggest. What looks solid and separate is actually

25:58

interconnected and infinitely divisible. That intuition? Modern physics has vindicated it.

26:04

Now look at the second one. Mind and consciousness. This is where things get really interesting

26:10

for contemporary philosophy. Anaxagoras introduced Naus as an organizing principle, intelligence

26:17

as fundamental to reality, not derivative from it. And that idea resonates with some cutting

26:23

edge debates in philosophy of mind today. There's a position called panpsychism, the idea that

26:29

consciousness isn't something that magically emerges from unconscious matter, but is actually

26:34

a fundamental feature of reality itself. Some serious philosophers and even some physicists

26:39

are taking this idea seriously again. Why? Because we still can't explain how consciousness arises

26:45

from purely physical processes. The hard problem of consciousness, how subjective experience

26:50

emerges from objective brain states, remains unsolved. Now, I'm not saying Anaxagoras solved

26:56

this problem, but he was asking the right question. What if mind isn't just an accident? What if

27:04

intelligence is woven into the fabric of reality from the beginning? And look at this last one.

27:10

Cosmic order. The idea that rotation and gradual separation create order from chaos, this parallels

27:18

modern cosmological theories in fascinating ways. Think about the Big Bang. and cosmic

27:23

inflation. We have this initial state of incredible density and heat, everything mixed together,

27:28

and then expansion, cooling, separation, galaxies form, stars form, planets form, order emerging

27:35

from chaos through physical processes. Or think about how solar systems form, rotating clouds

27:41

of gas and dust that gradually separate into distinct bodies through gravitational forces

27:46

and angular momentum. Anaxagoras' cosmic rotation isn't scientifically accurate in the details.

27:52

But the basic insight, that order emerges from chaos through natural processes involving motion

27:57

and separation, that's actually pretty close to what modern cosmology tells us. But here's

28:02

what really gets me about Anaxagoras' relevance today. We live in an age where we're constantly

28:08

told that science and philosophy are separate domains. That ancient philosophy is just historical

28:14

curiosity with no real connection to modern knowledge. That's wrong. An hexagoras shows

28:22

us that the deepest philosophical questions, what is matter? What is mind? How does order

28:28

emerge from chaos? These aren't just ancient puzzles. They're live questions that science

28:33

is still grappling with. And maybe, just maybe, engaging with how ancient thinkers approach

28:39

these questions can give us new perspectives on contemporary problems. Because sometimes

28:44

the most cutting-edge ideas are the ones that force us to reconsider assumptions we've been

28:48

making for centuries. Anaxagoras got exiled for challenging orthodoxy, but his ideas survived

28:55

because they touched something true about reality. And that's the power of philosophy. Good ideas

29:01

don't die. They evolve, they transform, they resurface in new contexts. So when you're thinking

29:08

about quantum mechanics, or consciousness, or cosmic evolution, remember, a guy in ancient

29:14

Athens was already asking these questions. And even though we have better tools now, We're

29:19

still working on the answers. That's not a bug. That's a feature. That's what makes philosophy

29:25

timeless. Alright, we've covered a lot of ground here. We've talked about cosmic mixtures and

29:30

mind, about exile and influence, about ancient ideas resonating with modern science. But let's

29:36

bring this home. Let's get to the heart of why Anaxagoras actually matters, not just as a

29:41

historical figure, but as someone who has something urgent to say to us right now. Look at this

29:46

first point. Intelligence underlies order. Here's what Anaxagoras did that was genuinely revolutionary.

29:54

He pioneered the idea that intelligence, not divine caprice, underlies cosmic order. Think

30:00

about what a massive shift that is. Before Anaxagoras, if you wanted to know why the world is the

30:05

way it is, you'd get mythology. Zeus threw a lightning bolt. Poseidon got angry. The gods

30:11

had a war. The universe is ordered because the gods decided to order it. and they could change

30:16

their minds tomorrow. But Anaxagoras says, No, there's a rational principle at work, mind

30:24

itself, nous, operating according to its own nature, bringing order out of chaos not through

30:30

whim or emotion, but through intelligence. This is the bridge between myth and rational explanation.

30:38

This is the moment when humanity starts to believe that we can understand the cosmos through reason

30:43

rather than just telling stories about it. And every scientific discovery since then, every

30:48

time we explain something through natural laws rather than supernatural intervention, we're

30:52

walking the path Anaxagoras opened up. Do you see how radical that is? How brave? To stand

30:59

up in a world saturated with religious mythology and say, the universe makes sense, intelligence

31:05

governs it, and we can figure it out. Now, look at the second one. Courage to challenge. His

31:13

daring challenges to religious orthodoxy remind us of philosophy's transformative power and

31:19

the personal costs of pursuing truth against established beliefs. Let's be honest about

31:24

this. Anaxagoras didn't just have interesting ideas. He had dangerous ideas. He looked at

31:30

the sun, an object of worship, and said it's just a rock. He explained eclipses mechanically

31:36

when people thought they were divine omens. He removed the gods from natural phenomena.

31:42

and it cost him everything. His home, his position, his influence, his friendship with Pericles,

31:49

all of it gone because he insisted on pursuing truth wherever it led, regardless of whether

31:55

it contradicted established beliefs. But here's the thing, here's what really matters, he did

32:00

it anyway. He knew the risks, he understood that challenging orthodoxy could destroy him.

32:05

And he did it anyway because the truth mattered more than safety. How many of us have that

32:10

kind of courage? How many of us are willing to speak uncomfortable truths when it might

32:14

cost us our careers, our reputations, our communities? Anaxagoras reminds us that philosophy isn't

32:21

just an intellectual game. It's a way of life that sometimes demands everything from us.

32:27

And the people who changed the world, the people who actually moved human understanding forward,

32:33

they were the ones willing to pay that price. And now look at this last one. And I want you

32:37

to really sit with this quote. All things were together. infinite both in number and in smallness.

32:44

And since these things are so, we must suppose that there are many things of all sorts in

32:49

all composite products. Anaxagoras invites us to see the universe as a dynamic, interconnected

32:55

whole shaped by mind, where everything truly contains elements of everything else. Think

33:01

about what this means for how we live. If everything contains everything else, then the boundaries

33:05

we draw between self and other, between us and them, between human and nature, These boundaries

33:11

are provisional. They're useful for navigation, but they're not ultimate truths. You contain

33:17

traces of the stars. The trees contain traces of you. We're all part of this cosmic mixture,

33:23

separated by degree rather than kind. And mind, intelligence, consciousness, purpose, permeates

33:29

it all. This isn't just abstract metaphysics. This is a vision of radical interconnection.

33:35

This is a philosophy that says you are not separate from the cosmos. You are the cosmos becoming

33:41

aware of itself. And if that's true, if we really are all part of this interconnected whole,

33:46

all governed by the same cosmic intelligence, then how we treat each other matters. How we

33:52

treat the natural world matters. Because there is no other. There's only the cosmic mixture

33:57

in different arrangements. So here's why Anaxagoras matters today, right now, in this moment. He

34:03

teaches us that intelligence underlies reality, that the universe is comprehensible. That reason

34:09

can guide us, that we're not just floating in meaningless chaos. He teaches us that pursuing

34:14

truth requires courage, that sometimes you have to stand against the crowd, even when it costs

34:20

you everything. And he teaches us that we're all connected, that the apparent separations

34:25

between things mask a deeper unity, and that mind shapes it all. Two and a half thousand

34:30

years ago, a man in ancient Athens looked at the cosmos and saw intelligence, interconnection,

34:35

and order. He spoke that truth even though it got him exiled. His ideas survived. They influenced

34:42

every philosopher who came after. They resonate with our best modern science. They challenge

34:48

us to see the world differently. That's not just history. That's philosophy doing what

34:52

it does best, transforming how we understand reality and how we live our lives. So the question

34:58

isn't whether Anaxagoras matters. The question is, what are you going to do with these ideas?

35:04

What truths are you willing to speak? What orthodoxies are you willing to challenge? How will you

35:09

live differently knowing that everything contains everything else, and that mind shapes it all?

35:14

And Axagoras can't answer those questions for you. But he can remind you that they're worth

35:19

asking, and sometimes that's exactly what philosophy is supposed to do.